Is Moving From 4G to 5G the Same As It Was From 3G to 4G?

It’s been only seven years between first LTE smartphones becoming available and today, as 5G slowly takes-off. So I was musing a bit if the move from 4G LTE to 5G NR is similar to what we had in 2012 when the world slowly moved from 3G UMTS to 4G LTE.

Back in 2012, the mobile Internet was still in its very infancy. The year before, the Samsung Galaxy S2, the far distant ancestor of today’s Galaxy S10 saw the light of day. A few experimental variants had LTE on board but the mass market LTE smartphone introduction only came with the Samsung Galaxy S3-LTE. As the name suggests, there was an S3 without LTE support.

Things look very similar today. There is an LTE-only version of the S10 in several flavors that probably outsells 5G variant by a wide margin. Also, back in 2012, most people had no need to buy the LTE version of the S3, UMTS was still fast enough and there was still ample capacity in 3G networks. But usage was rising fast, data prices were dropping and by the time the Samsung Galaxy S4 was released there was no 3G variant anymore.

If one extrapolates from this then the S10 is like the S2, and thus, speculatively, the S11 might be like the S3, i.e. there might be 4G and 5G variants. The S12 might then be like the S4, i.e. there might only be 5G variants. That would be mid-2021 if history repeats itself.

Also, from a network capacity point of view I can see today that in most places there is still ample capacity in 4G networks. But not everywhere. When I was in Vienna recently I could only get 15-20 Mbit/s in the city center in the evening in most places, despite the use of 3-Carrier Aggregation (CA) with a combined bandwidth of 50 MHz. So by the time there are only a 5G variants of flagship models, people in many city centers will likely feel the ‘4G slowdown’ due to rising use. But like back in the days of the S3, I expect that even in mid-2021, many devices in the sub-300 Euro range will not have 5G on board yet. Not that I can tell the future, but that’s what I expect when I look back 7 years.

So the move from 4G to 5G might indeed be very similar to the move from 3G to 4G was seven years ago. On the other hand there is one big difference: Back seven years ago, most networks used 5 MHz or 10 MHz of spectrum for 3G, which, compared to the 60-80 MHz used in city centers by many network operators today, is not that much. Put on top that 5G, in the best case, will ‘only’ add 100 MHz. While back in 2012 it was no problem at all to make a clean break and just disregard the 3G spectrum, this won’t work for 5G as it doesn’t add an order of magnitude of additional spectrum. So I expect that 5G will be used in the current Non-Standalone Mode for quite some time to come. Long enough, at least, until a significant portion of the devices out there have migrated to 5G and network operators dare to re-farm the LTE spectrum for 5G. And this is where my crystal ball really gets hazy. I have no idea, when, let’s say 90% of the spectrum will be used for 5G and only 10% remains for LTE, and perhaps some for 2G and 3G. Will GSM ever die? Probably, but when? Yes, In the US, for example, AT&T has already discontinued service. But I don’t see a move like that in most European countries. Too much GSM-only machine to machine hardware in the market.

It will be interesting in 2022 to look back to this post and muse about which predictions turned out to be right and which ones did not.

4 thoughts on “Is Moving From 4G to 5G the Same As It Was From 3G to 4G?”

  1. Hi Martin,

    i think you are missing one point: coverage of LTE was from the beginning better than with 3G. I remember my S3-LTE (moved from Telekom to Vodafone just to get B20 LTE) and my first trip down from hamburg to basel by car. I had very often 4G, never 3G and often 2G…
    today the same: people looking for LTE becaus of the much better coverage than with 3G.
    Its not the speed, its the coverage.
    And with 5G you will have bandwith which is not needed. And bad coverage which is also not needed.

    i complain when i have less than 100mbit speed, but i dont know ANYBODY that has any idea about speed. If they have bad youtube speed they complain. But typicaly they even dont understand what is HD, Full HD and streaming bandwith of 1mbit, 2mbit etc. Youtube and Whatsapp must work, and everywhere. Than its ok.

    Best regards from Hamburg

    1. Good point about coverage! I don’t agree with the 5G bandwidth not needed. In the past 12 months it has become more and more common in many places I’ve been for networks to become severely congested. In addition, more people than ever complain about congested LTE in rural areas. Every Hertz counts 🙂 Will write a couple of blog entries where I’ve encountered congestion recently, it’s unfortunately a rising trend.

  2. I think you will also find a very strong correlation between uptake and iPhone support (especially in Europe & US). So my personal opinion is that until Apple release a 5G capable iPhone (Sept 2020 most probably) the uptake of 5G will be very slow..

  3. Hi Martin,
    I think there will be already a lot of 5G mid-market phones in 2020. Device and chipset manufacturers are pushing 5G a lot. Compared to 2012, there are a lot more “5G variants” of existing devices available, with mid-market phones like the Samsung Galaxy A90 5G already showing up in the market. Therefore, I think we will see a much faster growing market share of 5G phones compared to the 4G launch.
    It is also remarkable that 5G is the first mobile network generation with a significant amount of attractive devices available, even if the networks are nearly non-existent. With 4G, networks were deployed starting from 2010 and we already had a pretty decent coverage when first 4G smartphones went on sale in 2012.

    I am personally using a Xiaomi Mi Mix 3 5G smartphone in Bonn @ Deutsche Telekom 5G network. I am really impressed by the speed, but coverage is limited to a few hundred metres.

Comments are closed.