Location: Another Diminishing Opportunity for Mobile Operators

Location based services have been the holy grail in mobile for at least half a decade now and I wonder what hasn’t been proposed to mobile operators over the past years from standardized Mobile Location Centers to A-GPS assistance their network could supply to mobile devices? Yet, they haven’t been able to figure out what to do with it, or more precisely how to monetize it, except for a applications such as location based pricing of voice calls, which do not require interaction with any equipment outside their own network.

When looking at current high end mobile devices from Nokia and others on the market, they all include GPS chips now and thus no longer require network operators for acquiring location information for them. The current generation of GPS chips require about 20 seconds to get a first position fix which is already good enough for many applications. With a server in the Internet that supplies the location of all GPS satellites to the GPS chip, this time is reduced to around 5 seconds, which is almost instantaneous from a user perspective. The only piece in the value chain the mobile operator is thus still required for is to connect the device to the server on the Internet.

According to a Sirf representative at the recent Mobile World Congress, the mobile only requests satellite position information from the network without sending any information such as a cell-id that could give away the approximate location of the device. Further according to Sirf, network based A-GPS assistance that sends satellite position information to a device could speed up the process to reach first time to fix times of less than a second. However, I think it is unlikely that mobile network operators will ever do this and a delay of around 5 seconds is short enough for a good user experience anyway.

So the room to maneuver for mobile operators in the location domain is getting small these days. But would it have made a difference if they’ve had another 5 years of time to work on this topic? Outside players on the other hand already put the emerging GPS capabilities to good use. Nokia Maps, Google Maps, etc. etc. have come from nowhere in the past 12 months and now offer positioning, car and pedestrian navigation, recommendation, finding point of interests, city guides, location dependent search, etc. etc.

Another holy grail, location based mobile advertising, however, is still a niche that offers lots of opportunities for network operators as network based location information is an important key. A company active in this space is Seekerwireless, and I leave you with a link to their site to explore further.

Java and BREW

Every now and then I stumble over BREW, an API for third party applicatins on mobile phones. Since it seems to be mostly implementend in CDMA phones in the U.S., I haven’t come into personal contact with it and thus always wondered what the difference is to Java ME. After doing some research it looks to me like they have one thing in common: They both offer a cross device environment to programs. Apart from this, however, there don’t seem to be many similarities. BREW supports several programing languages including Java (but with a different API from Jave ME) and C++. While programs developed with Java ME can be distributed without the consent of the operator, BREW applications need to be certified and can only be distributed by the operator. So the business model for developers is quite different since they need to make a deal with each network operator they want to deploy their application with. In addition, network operators have no obligation to distribute a program, so developers and users are at the full mercy of the operator. To me that does not only look like a walled garden but more like a closed fortress. An environment with a future?

Vodafone To Trial Image Recognition Search

While waiting for the train this morning I read on Intomobile (sorry, can’t provide the link when moblogging) that Vodafone Germany will start an image recognition search trial in cooperation with news tabloid “Bild”. Readers can get more information on specially tagged articles (and maybe advertisments) by taking a picture and sending it to a Vodafone image recognition server. The server analyzes the picture and returns the requested information (I assume by MMS). That sounds very much like the technology from Barcelona based company DAEM Interactive. If that’s you, well done and lots of success! For the sake of the project I hope Vodafone thinks a bit about pricing before launching the project. The standard price of 39 euro cents for an MMS would be a major showstopper.

Opera Mini Statistics

Interesting numbers I’ve been given during the MWC in Barcelona last week: To date, the Opera Mini browser for mobile phones has been download 35 million times. Currently, the browser is downloaded 100.000 times a day! According to Opera, their Transcoding Servers for Opera Mini serves about 1.5 billion pages a month. They estimate that the total traffic going to their servers represents around 25% of the total Internet traffic of Norway, the home country of opera. Despite Norway only being a small country it says a lot about the quick evolution of accessing the web from mobile devices.

Opera Mini Should Have An Option to Disregard Mobile Optimized Pages

One should think that it’s a good thing if a web site has a mobile optimized version of their content. With Opera Mini, a mobile browser that compresses full web pages in a way that they can be nicely viewed on mobile phones, I have quickly discovered that this is not always the case. Here are take two examples:

  • Amazon: While the mobile pages are loading a bit faster than Amazon’s full web pages the mobile version only contains a fraction of the information of the full page. When looking at an article I can not even browse the description. Sorry guys, that’s too limiting. I want to see the full page compressed by Opera Mini and not Amazon’s mobile version.
  • Another example is Spiegel online, a German news magazine. Again, the mobile version, if reachable at all from Opera Mini only contains a fraction of the articles and pictures present on the full page. Again, I would very much prefer Opera to fetching the full web page and then compressing it.

I am not sure if Opera is actively requesting the ‘mobile’ versions of these web sites (I don’t even want to say ‘mobile optimized’ anymore) or if the web sites choose themselves to send the mobile optimized version based on the browser identity string. If so, Opera should make the request with a full web browser identity. Opera, any chance of adding a ‘mobile/full version’ selection feature in the next release?

The Carnival Of The Mobilists Blasts Off Again

Cotmbutton
This week the Carnival of the Mobilists is hosted by Taptu over at Taptology. Lots of stuff to find there around mobile application development and an avalanche started by Michael Mace, commented by many fellow blog writers. Haven’t seen so many individual blog responses on a blog post of someone for quite some time. Looks like Michael has struck a nerve 🙂 For this and more, head over to the Carnival and enjoy.

Puzzled About The Antenna Of An FM Transmitter In A Mobile Phone

The specs for the latest and greatest Nokia N78 lists a new feature which so far has only been available as an add-on for various products: An FM-transmitter to stream music and podcasts wirelessly to a Hifi set or the car stereo. What puzzles me is where they put the antenna inside the mobile or how it looks like!? At 100 MHz, the wavelength is around 300 cm. Even at a quarter of the wavelength the antenna still needs to have a length of 75 centimeters. How does that fit into a mobile phone? Can anyone shed some light on how this works in practice?

TWIN: Neuf Starts Voice Service over GSM / Wifi

Neuf Telecom, an ADSL and fiber Internet service provider in France has started a fixed line voice service replacement offer via GSM and Wifi enabled phones. The difference to UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Acccess) services that use Wifi/ADSL to connect back to the wireless network, their solution is a true VoIP over Wifi solution, (probably) using naked SIP over Wifi. For the GSM part of their service they use SFR’s mobile network. For them, UMA does not make sense as they are a fixed line operator and do not have a mobile network. According to their FAQ, voice calls initiated over a Wifi network to fixed line numbers in France and a number of other countries are included in the monthly subscription fee. Further, the FAQ says the mobile can be reached both at home and outside via it’s mobile number but doesn’t mention anything about being reachable with a fixed line number while attached to Wifi. So it looks like VoIP over Wifi is only used for outgoing calls for the moment. Let’s see if they are bold enough to add Voice Call Continuity (VCC) to their offer to allow seamless roaming between GSM and Wifi and a fixed line number to be reachable for an acceptable price. Unlike most UMA services that can just make use of Wifi access points allowed by the network operator this solution works over any Wifi access point that has been configured in the phone, i.e. also from abroad. Very nice! I’d like to get one of those phones into my hands to see how well the integration of the service has been made into the GSM phones they offer for the service.